Escape on a Budget: 10 Private Islands You Can Rent for Under $100

Picture yourself unwinding on a private island paradise—without draining your wallet. Believe it or not, there are hidden gems around the world where you can enjoy an exclusive island escape at surprisingly affordable prices. Based on 2024 data, here are ten private islands you can rent for under $100 per person per night.

1. Brother Island, El Nido, Philippines

Tucked away in the Philippines, Brother Island is a tropical haven with powdery white sand and swaying coconut palms. A charming two-story beachfront house hosts up to 10 guests, making it perfect for group getaways.

• Cost: Around $381 per night for the whole island—just about $38 per person.
• Amenities: Includes a full staff with a housekeeper and private chef, all meals provided, optional massage services, and access to hiking trails, fishing spots, and snorkeling.
• Things to Do: Go island hopping, trek through a mini rainforest, or savor fresh-caught seafood by the sea.

2. Whiskey Island, New York, USA

Perched along the New York–Canada border, Whiskey Island offers a rustic, three-acre escape steeped in historical charm. This hidden gem features a vintage lodge that blends cozy comfort with timeless character.

• Cost: Around $1,450 per night for up to 15 guests—roughly $97 per person.
• Amenities: An eight-bedroom historic lodge with multiple fireplaces, antique stained glass windows, and old-world ambiance.
• Things to Do: Discover the island’s rich history, cast a line for some relaxing fishing, or simply soak in the serene natural surroundings.

3. Old House Cay, Hilton Head, South Carolina, USA

Just a short 10-minute boat ride from Hilton Head Island, Old House Cay is a secluded cluster of private islands perfect for an off-grid escape.

• Cost: From $589 per night for up to six guests—about $98 per person.
• Amenities: A sustainable off-grid home, scenic walkways linking the islands, and a private boat dock.
• Things to Do: Swim, fish, go crabbing, or simply unwind with stunning views of the Intracoastal Waterway.

4. Little Peter Oasis, Belize

Set in a tranquil lagoon, this three-acre private island in Belize features charming overwater bungalows for the ultimate tropical escape.

• Cost: Around $100 per night per cabana.
• Amenities: Cozy overwater bungalows with direct lagoon access.
• Things to Do: Swim in calm, clear waters, snorkel among vibrant marine life, and explore the beauty of the surrounding sea.

5. Blackbird Island, Minnesota, US

Tucked away at Minnesota’s northernmost point near the Canadian border, Blackbird Island offers a peaceful retreat surrounded by nature.

• Cost: About $200 per night for up to eight guests—just $25 per person.
• Amenities: A rustic cabin with direct access to fishing and boating.
• Things to Do: Cast a line, paddle the scenic waters, or simply relax and take in the untouched beauty of the island.

6. Margisle, Maine, USA

Nestled in Maine’s Pemaquid Pond, Margisle is a charming private island perfect for a quiet lakeside escape.

• Cost: Around $150 per night for up to six guests—just $25 per person.
• Amenities: A cozy log cabin with direct access to kayaking and fishing.
• Things to Do: Paddle through peaceful waters, reel in a fresh catch, or explore the scenic beauty of the pond.

7. Estrada Island, Nicaragua

Located near Granada in the heart of Lake Nicaragua, Estrada Island offers a laid-back tropical escape surrounded by water and nature.

• Cost: Around $150 per night for up to six guests—about $25 per person.
• Amenities: A private villa with easy access to the lake and all its adventures.
• Things to Do: Swim in warm freshwater, kayak around the island, and discover the natural beauty of Lake Nicaragua.

8. Little Raccoon Key, Georgia, USA

Just off Georgia’s coast, Little Raccoon Key is a secluded gem offering a unique blend of comfort and conservation.

• Cost: Around $525 per night for up to four guests—about $131 per person.
• Amenities: A stylish overwater bungalow with exclusive access to a protected marine reserve.
• Things to Do: Snorkel vibrant waters, cast a line, or explore the rich biodiversity of the surrounding ecosystem.

9. Hideaway Caye, Belize

Tucked away in Belize’s South Water Caye Marine Reserve, Hideaway Caye provides a one-of-a-kind overwater bungalow escape.

• Cost: Around $350 per night for up to four guests—just $88 per person.
• Amenities: A cozy overwater bungalow with exclusive access to the vibrant marine reserve.
• Things to Do: Snorkel among colorful reefs, fish in pristine waters, and immerse yourself in the beauty of the marine reserve.

10. Plocica Island, Croatia

Plocica Island is home to a historic lighthouse dating back to 1887, offering an unforgettable stay with a blend of history and coastal charm.

• Cost: Rates range from $100 to $1,000 per night, depending on the season.
• Amenities: Stay in the iconic lighthouse with access to a serene sandy lagoon.
• Things to Do: Swim in crystal-clear waters, explore the lighthouse’s rich history, and enjoy the stunning Adriatic Sea views.

These private islands provide unforgettable experiences at a fraction of the cost. Whether you’re dreaming of a tropical getaway or a cozy, rustic escape, these budget-friendly options make the fantasy of renting your own island a reality.

Found your perfect paradise? Share the magic with your friends! 🥰

Explore our website:

• The Ultimate Bird Travel Backpack Carrier for Your Feathered Friend
• Luxury Camping: The Futuristic Solar-Powered Tent
• This Bicycle Camper Offers A Mobile Living Space For One, Perfect For Solo Adventurers
• Garage on the Go: Unveiling the $1.7 Million Luxury Motorhome with Space for Your Car

Note: DEARTARCH is a partner of the Amazon Associate program and other affiliate programs. This means we do not handle any of the products shown on the website. We earn a small commission for referring sales through one of the links placed on our website. Thanks.